After Dam Removal, can the restoration process include some damming to create a lake?
by Chris LaVoie
Good question — the short answer is yes, but only under very specific conditions, and it typically isn’t the goal of federally licensed dam removals. I asked my research assistant to come up with some answers for us. Here’s the breakdown:
1. Purpose of Dam Removal
- Most federally licensed dam removals (overseen by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, or FERC, if it was a hydropower project) happen because the dam is outdated, unsafe, environmentally damaging, or no longer economically viable.
- The primary restoration goal is usually to restore free-flowing river conditions for fish passage, sediment transport, and natural ecosystem recovery.
2. Creating a Lake After Removal
- If the restoration plan includes building a smaller dam, berm, or impoundment to create a lake or wetland, this would need its own federal and state approvals (sometimes even a new license).
- Agencies like the Army Corps of Engineers, state water resources departments, and often U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service would need to sign off.
- The new impoundment can’t defeat the ecological purpose of the removal — for example, blocking fish passage again.
3. Common Compromises
- Instead of a full lake, sometimes side-channel wetlands, ponds, or beaver dam analogs are created as part of restoration. These can provide habitat diversity without recreating a major barrier.
- In rare cases, small recreational lakes or ponds may be designed if they don’t interfere with the river’s restored flow and meet environmental requirements.
4. Key Limitation
If the original dam removal is tied to fish passage restoration (salmon, trout, endangered species, etc.), then building a new dam — even a smaller one — would almost certainly not be allowed in the river’s main channel. Any new waterbody would usually need to be off-channel.
✅ Bottom line: Restoration can include some limited impoundments or artificial lakes, but only if they don’t undermine the ecological goals of dam removal and if they pass a fresh round of permitting.
Case study examples of U.S. dam removals where a lake or pond was intentionally included in the restoration plan.
there are projects where a federally licensed dam is removed, the river is restored to free-flowing conditions, and the plan intentionally includes some form of “re-impoundment”—but almost always as small, off-channel ponds/wetlands or grade-control riffles, not a new on-channel lake. A few concrete examples:
- Klamath Basin (CA/OR): off-channel ponds built for salmon
As part of basin restoration linked to the big Klamath dam removals, NOAA and partners created two off-channel ponds on lower‐river tributaries (Terwer & McGarvey Creeks) to provide refuge/overwintering habitat for coho. These are deliberately ponded features connected to a free-flowing river network—i.e., “some damming,” but off-channel rather than a reservoir on the mainstem. NOAA Fisheries+1 - Milltown Dam (MT): floodplain with wetlands in a new state park
After Superfund cleanup and removal of Milltown Dam at the Clark Fork/Blackfoot confluence, the restoration built a new river channel and floodplain that includes wetlands; the site is now Milltown State Park. It’s not a mainstem lake, but the design explicitly includes permanently ponded wetland waterbodies within the restored floodplain. Sems PublishingMontana FWPMontana Department of Justice - New England & Mid-Atlantic removals: “nature-like” riffles/grade control
Many removals install rock-riffle grade-control structures (sometimes called “rock ramps”) to hold some upstream water surface elevation, create pool habitat, and ensure fish passage—functionally a low, permeable weir rather than a dam. Examples include projects documented in American Rivers’ 2023 summary and Massachusetts design reports. American Riverseeaonline.eea.state.ma.usweymouth.ma.us - Oxbow/side-channel restoration (Midwest & West): small lakes reconnected
Restoration often excavates or recreates oxbow lakes/ponds alongside the main river to boost habitat diversity and thermal refuges—again, ponded water that’s off-channel while the river itself runs free. Guidance and case studies from TNC and peer-reviewed work describe these measures. The Nature ConservancyWiley Online Library
The practical takeaway
- If the goal is a recreation-scale lake on the main channel, that usually conflicts with the core objectives of dam removal (fish passage, sediment transport, water quality).
- If your goal is placid water for wildlife, angling, or aesthetics, planners commonly achieve it with off-channel ponds/wetlands or rock-riffle “grade control” that maintains some upstream depth without recreating a barrier.
Either option could offer boating opportunities, just different opportunities.
If saving the dam isn’t an option, how can we salvage the most important benefits of Leaburg Lake for residents and visitors?
Important Notes:
Is it a Done Deal? A local group of Leaburg Lake residents and other interested parties have created a group called Oregon Citizens for Energy Security with the intention of helping to save the lake. Follow the link to learn more.
MCP’s position on Removing or Keeping the Dam: McKenzie Community Partnership nor Chris LaVoie, the author has taken a side on the issue. we recognize that both improving Salmon health and the recreation benefits of the lake have merits. We want to help educate and promote understanding of the issues to help us reach teh right decision. Hopefully we can find a win – win in the end.